Friday, March 02, 2007

The Persuaders

Yesterday, Adam Ellis (who once again is staying with my family, along with Matt Wilson) did a blogpost with a transcript from a Frontline series called the Persuaders. It was a very interesting piece and I'm going to post the quote that he did.

DOUGLAS ATKIN, Merkley and Partners Advertising: When I was a brand manager at Proctor & Gamble, my job was basically to make sure the product was good, develop new advertising copy, design the pack. Now a brand manager has an entirely different kind of responsibility. In fact, they have more responsibility. Their job now is to create and maintain a whole meaning system for people, through which they get identity and understanding of the world. Their job now is to be a community leader.

DOUGLAS RUSHKOFF: Ad strategist Douglas Atkin, an expert on the relationship between consumers and brands, says he had a eureka moment one night during a focus group.

DOUGLAS ATKIN: I was in a research facility watching eight people rhapsodize about a sneaker. And I thought, "Where is this coming from? This is, at the end of the day, a piece of footwear." But the terms they were using were evangelical. So I thought, if these people are expressing cult-like devotion, then why not study cults? Why not study the original? Find out why people join cults and apply that knowledge to brands.

FALUN GONG MEMBER: I'm loyal to this practice because it's done so much for me.

DOUGLAS RUSHKOFF: If Atkin could find what pushed a person from mere fan to devoted disciple, perhaps he could market that knowledge.

WRESTLING FAN: Most of the people I discuss the WWF with know that it's not a sport, you know, it's a masculine ballet.

DOUGLAS RUSHKOFF: So he compared dozens of groups he considered cults with so called "cult brands," from Hare Krishna to Harley Davidson–

VW BEETLE OWNER: If you're smart and kind of individual, that's what you drive.

DOUGLAS RUSHKOFF: –from Falun Gong to Mac.

MACINTOSH USER: I think there's something about Mac users. Like, they get it.

DEADHEAD: We just had discovered something.

LINUX USER: They realized there are other people like them, and they cooperate on certain projects, and it's part of belonging to the tribe.

DOUGLAS ATKIN: And the conclusion was this, is that people, whether they're joining a cult or joining a brand, do so for exactly the same reasons. They need to belong, and they want to make meaning. We need to figure out what the world is all about, and we need the company of others. It's simply that.

Saturn is a really good example. It's a mass cult brand. For example, 45,000 people turned up to spend their holiday vacation time at the factory in Tennessee instead of going to Disney World or the Grand Canyon. Now, why would they do that? It's because they wanted to meet other people who own Saturns. They wanted to meet the rest of the Saturn family. They wanted to meet the people who made the car. The people who made the car wanted to meet them. And the people who ran the Saturn business knew that.

DOUGLAS RUSHKOFF: They not only knew it, they turned it into an ad, which only brought more people into the "Saturn family."

[television commercial] We called it the Saturn homecoming. They could see where the idea for a new kind of car company had taken shape, and we could thank them for believing we could do it.

DOUGLAS ATKIN: They created a great meaning system for Saturn in those fantastic commercials. Their meaning system was based on old-time values of community. It was a kind of an icon that America yearned for but couldn't find anymore.

DOUGLAS RUSHKOFF: And that's the object of emotional branding: to fill the empty places where non-commercial institutions, like schools and churches, (emphasis mine) might once have done the job. Brands become more than just a mark of quality, they become an invitation to a longed-for lifestyle, a ready-made identity.

KEITH REINHARD, Chairman, DDB Worldwide: The campaign for iPod is remarkable. When I see the poster as I'm passing by, when I go on the Web site and it comes to life and I hear the music track going, and then when I put my little iPod ear-pods on and I see the white cords against my black jacket, I'm in that poster, and the poster is me! And then the music, my music, comes over my iPod, and it's a brand experience.

NAOMI KLEIN: When you listen to brand managers talk, you can get quite carried away in this idea that they actually are fulfilling these needs that we have for community and narrative and transcendence. But in the end, it is, you know, a laptop and a pair of running shoes. And they might be great, but they're not actually going to fulfill those needs, but which serves them very well because, of course, that means that you have to go shopping again.

So what does this say to us? It seems to me that there are a couple of things.

1) There is a lot of thought going into getting us to buy things.

2) What advertisers and companies are figuring out is that there is a lack of community that people are feeling and by tapping into that, they create brands that people really have this burning desire to buy. In other words, they've figured out how to get us to replace God in our lives with stuff and to not even miss God.

This might be why Lee Camp associates marketing with prostitution.


Carrie said...

Yikes!! Hey Phil. I came across your website today and I feel I must speak on behalf of marketers everywhere! Most businesses rely on marketing/sales for their own livelihood in some way. Usually indirectly, but if no one is out promoting iPods or the local University, there will be fewer people buying them or attending, and therefore fewer people with jobs. I disagree w/shady marketing tactics, but most businesses understand the importance of marketing in order for their businesses to successfully operate. Even churches do it - maybe that should be a point of discussion. And these marketers are correct in their assessment that people do need community and more & more people are not finding that in a church community. Maybe THAT's the real problem here. Trying to explain the fabulous benefits of my gym is NOT the same as prostitution. Love Lee Camp, but I must disagree there. See you at church!

Darin said...

Thanks for the information. invaluable.

Justin said...

Carrie, I don't think any of what you said makes Camp's ideas any less relevant. The point is that marketing is manipulating people to believe that they need something that they don't. We could live on a lot less (and as Christians we should) but we're hit over the head with ads subliminally explaining to us that we aren't cool, or sexy, or smart, if we don't have a certain product. I don't know if I'd go with prostitution as a comparison, but when you try to sell something not on the basis of why its needed, but through psychological stimulants (the whole sexy, cool, smart stuff) then you are getting on shaky ground.

Template Designed by Douglas Bowman - Updated to Beta by: Blogger Team
Modified for 3-Column Layout by Hoctro